1441 Shares

What makes a 9mm stronger than a.38 spc?

What makes a 9mm stronger than a.38 spc? Topic: Shell case sizes
July 20, 2019 / By Stan
Question: I know that ballistically the 9mm is a more effective round than the .38 spc, but... how is that possible? The .38 shell is much larger than the 9mm, so wouldn't it hold more powder?
Best Answer

Best Answers: What makes a 9mm stronger than a.38 spc?

Otniel Otniel | 2 days ago
John pretty much got it, 9mm is built to take more pressure than the .38, the case size difference is the .38 was developed as a black powder cartridge which is much bulkier than smokeless and requires a larger volume to generate similar powers. To add to his answer more pressure in the 9mm means it fires at a higher velocity, which is what makes the difference. Bullet diameter is essentially the same (0.002" difference), bullets can be found in comparable weights such as 110 and 125 for .38 115 and 124 for 9mm It's not fair comparing 148 gr (wadcutter) vs 147 gr, or mentioning the 158 which has no real close 9mm counterpart. Take everything similar and you will get somewhere around a 200 fps advantage give or take for the 9mm; .38 +p evens this out a lot Actually if you look through a reloading manual powder charges are quite similar between the two when using the same powder and similar weight bullet. more case room = less pressure and vice-versa
👍 112 | 👎 2
Did you like the answer? What makes a 9mm stronger than a.38 spc? Share with your friends

We found more questions related to the topic: Shell case sizes


Otniel Originally Answered: Why do you think God made men stronger than women?
I believe God made men stronger to be a provider and protector for women,but unfortunately,some men abuse that power by "lording" it over women like they themselves are God. In Bible times,men had the final word in any situation,and women were to obey. Fortunately,we have evolved ,and though we may not be as strong physically as men,we are stronger in other ways. Can you imagine a man going through the birthing process? Me,either. And these days,it takes a 2-person income to make it,and in many cases now,the women,not the men,are becoming the main breadwinners,while many guys are becoming stay-at-home dads. I see nothing wrong with that. It just goes to show that a woman CAN do anything a man can do,and that we've come a long way from caveman days.

Lester Lester
Remember, it was filling the cases with powders of the day. The .38 Special is slightly older than the 9mm. Right in that time period, powders were being improved like crazy. So the 9mm could get more power out of less powder. Once they developed the specs for each cartridge, you couldn't just go and increase their power. It would damage the guns or be dangerous.
👍 40 | 👎 1

Jamin Jamin
Actually the .38 sp bullet is .357" and the 9mm bullet is .355". It is all chamber pressure. The .357 case is .1" longer than the .38 sp case to prevent the .357 from being fired in a .38 sp that was designed for lower chamber pressure. Everything else but the chamber pressure is the same. The .357 is rated for a higher chamber pressure than the 9mm.
👍 39 | 👎 0

Frank Frank
9 mm Parabellum is loaded to about twice the pressure of 38 Special, about 32,000 CUP vs. about 16,000 CUP. There's something to be said for having a case full of propellant, but there are also advantages to keeping pressures low.
👍 38 | 👎 -1

Dayton Dayton
It's slower and has more energy. It was loaded to be what a handgun caliber is supposed to be: heavy and slow. The 9mm is to damn fast to be an effective defensive handgun caliber. And it is easy to overpenetrate.
👍 37 | 👎 -2

Dayton Originally Answered: How do I make my internet stronger?
In order to ramp up your wireless connection, take the following courses of action: 1. Swap your router for a more powerful model: The tech team at Broadband Choices recommend most routers made by Linksys, Netgear and Belkin. Additionally, a router that does the new, faster draft N (802.11n) would be both preferable and future proof. On top of these suggestions, PC Pro Magazine favours the D-Link DIR-655 for long range and rural use. Although relatively expensive in relation to standard wireless routers, I found one of these on Amazon Marketplace for £76. 2. Consider purchasing a booster: A good quality booster (such as the Hawking Technologies booster) can increase the output power of a wireless signal by up to 600%. Signal boosters capture stronger signals from the outside wireless network and amplify the signal inside your network, thus improving your wireless coverage. It’s that simple. 3. Position your router wisely: The best position for your wireless router is either high or low, and away for any walls, metal, appliances or copper pipes. Attics and lofts are popular locations for the positioning of wireless routers. For some households, the attic is an inappropriate location for the router due to severe heat or lack of access. In these cases, a high shelf or bookcase would make a canny substitute. Try placing your router in a convenient place first and take it from there. 4. Replace your antenna: If your router is near an outside wall, half of the wireless signals will be sent outside your home, and much of your router's power will be wasted. Some router manufacturers sell external omnidirectional antennas that are significanly stronger than the routers built in antenna. Upgrade to a hi-gain antenna that focuses the wireless signals only one direction. 5. Add a Wireless Repeater: Wireless repeaters extend your wireless network range without requiring you to add any extra wiring. They additionally offer an easy way to increase the effective coverage of your wireless network. A wireless repeater will bounce signals, which may not have had the density to reach the destination device of their own accord, to remote wireless devices. 6. Change Your Wireless Channel: Wireless routers can broadcast across a number of different channels, similar to the way radio stations use a variety of channels. Try altering your wireless router's channel through its configuration page to see if your signal gets stronger. You don't need to change your computer's configuration, because it'll automatically detect the new channel. 7. Group your brands: While routers and network adapters from different manufacturers should work in harmony with each other, you often get better performance if you pick a router and network adapter from the same supplier. Consider choosing all your hardware from the same brand, in some cases performance can be radically improved should you adopt this approach. 8. Upgrade: If you're using an 802.11b wireless network and you're unhappy with the performance, consider replacing your router and network adapters with 802.11g-compatible equipment.

If you have your own answer to the question shell case sizes, then you can write your own version, using the form below for an extended answer.